The transition written into the statute
New York City's non-primary-residence surcharge is scheduled to enter a second phase on July 1, 2028. The shift would revalue condominiums and cooperative units using comparable sales rather than the initial DOF market values, and it would move those properties toward the rate schedule currently applied to one-, two- and three-family homes. The change is written into the statute signed May 28, 2026, and it would take effect unless Albany repeals or amends the law before then.
The first phase runs through June 30, 2028. During that window, condos and co-ops with DOF market values above $1 million are exposed to a 4 percent surcharge if the unit is not a primary residence; the rate rises to 5.25 percent between $3 million and $5 million, and 6.5 percent above $5 million. Houses face a different schedule: 0.8 percent for market values between $5 million and $15 million, 1.05 percent from $15 million to $25 million, and 1.3 percent above $25 million.
Phase 2 would narrow that gap. DOF is to use comparable-sales information to establish values for condos and co-ops, then calculate the surcharge using those figures. Condos and co-ops then move onto the schedule that already applies to houses: no surcharge below $5 million, 0.8 percent from $5 million to $15 million, 1.05 percent from $15 million to $25 million and 1.3 percent above $25 million. The $1 million and $3 million thresholds and the 4, 5.25 and 6.5 percent rates end with Phase 1.
What comparable-sales revaluation means
Phase 1 uses the DOF market value that appears on the Notice of Property Value—the same figure DOF calculates for regular property-tax purposes. For condos and co-ops, DOF sets that value with the income method it uses for property tax, which usually lands well below what the units sell for. The surcharge applies to the full market value once the unit crosses the threshold; it is not marginal.
Phase 2 would replace that method with one based on actual sales of comparable units. DOF's final-rule notice states that the surcharge notice will show the surcharge amount based on the applicable Phase 1 or Phase 2 market value. The statute does not specify which sales DOF will use, how recent they must be, or how DOF will adjust for differences in size, condition or location. Because the Phase 2 value is meant to track sale prices, most units should expect a figure well above today's DOF market value; the details will decide by how much.
What any one unit owes will depend on how DOF applies the comparable-sales method to it. A unit in a building with few recent sales, or in a neighbourhood where comparable transactions are sparse, may see a different outcome than a unit in a building with frequent turnover.
The move toward the house schedule
Phase 2 changes both the value and the rates for condos and co-ops. A unit with a $2 million DOF value in Phase 1 pays 4 percent, or $80,000 a year. In Phase 2 that unit owes nothing if its comparable-sales value stays under $5 million. If comparable sales put it at $6 million, it pays 0.8 percent, or $48,000. At $16 million it pays 1.05 percent, or $168,000. Each rate applies to the full value, not just the amount above the threshold.
Conquest's analysis of DOF's July 2026 Supplemental Market Value Roll shows 16,452 condo and co-op units in the $1 million to $3 million band, where the Phase 1 surcharge averages $58,048. Another 722 units fall between $3 million and $5 million, with an average surcharge of $192,575. Only 197 units exceed $5 million in Phase 1. In Phase 2 the question for each of them is whether a sale-based value clears $5 million. Units that stay below it drop out of the surcharge; units above it pay a lower rate on a much higher value.
Houses already pay on this schedule, and Phase 2 leaves it unchanged for them. What changes is that condos and co-ops join it, valued on what comparable units sell for.
The 2031 sunset and what litigation would not change
The surcharge provisions contain a sunset: the law expires June 30, 2031 unless Albany extends it. Phase 2 would therefore run three years, from July 1, 2028 through June 30, 2031. The statute does not establish a process for DOF to publish Phase 2 values before 2028, and no official materials reviewed establish a final Phase 2 valuation for any particular property.
A lower court issued an order on September 29, 2026 requiring the City to remove the existing supplemental roll, cancel previously mailed notices, and issue new notices containing information required by the court. The City appealed and invoked the automatic stay; implementation continued. On November 4, 2026, a four-justice Appellate Division, Second Department panel reversed the lower court on standing grounds—the petitioners lack standing because appearing on the roll or receiving a notice is not an injury. The rollout, roll and notices stand. The merits of the rollout were not decided.
The Comptroller's official bond disclosure states that the Richmond County litigation challenged the City's process for implementing the surcharge, not the legality of the surcharge under state law. Two constitutional challenges to the statute itself are pending in Suffolk County Supreme Court: Steve Wynn with Wilbur and Hilary Geary Ross v. State, filed September 28, 2026, and a group of homeowners plus a NYC co-op v. State, represented by Randy Mastro and Dechert, filed September 29, 2026. No decision has been issued as of November 10, 2026. Mastro has said he expects a decision around December 2026.
A successful procedural challenge could require corrected notices, revised determinations or additional administrative steps for the current tax year. It would not repeal Article 30-C, eliminate the July 1, 2028 statutory transition, or remove the 2031 sunset. A successful constitutional challenge could invalidate the statute entirely, which would eliminate both Phase 1 and Phase 2. Until a court rules on the merits of the constitutional claims, the statute remains operative and the Phase 2 transition remains scheduled.
What owners should watch
The exemption-application deadline for the 2026–27 tax year was October 13, 2026. DOF extended it three times: from August 21 and August 24 to September 18, then to October 6, then to October 13. Owners who missed the deadline may still challenge DOF's valuation or primary-residence determination through the Tax Commission; the deadline for Tax Class 2 properties is March 1, 2027, and for Tax Class 1 properties March 15, 2027.
DOF has not published a Phase 2 valuation methodology, a list of comparable sales it will use, or a timeline for releasing Phase 2 values before July 1, 2028. The statute requires DOF to value condos and co-ops on comparable sales, but the official materials reviewed do not establish how DOF will apply that to individual units. The number that will matter is a unit's likely sale value against the single $5 million line: below it, no Phase 2 surcharge; above it, 0.8 to 1.3 percent of that value.
The two constitutional challenges in Suffolk County are the cases to watch. A decision invalidating the statute would eliminate the surcharge entirely; a decision upholding it would leave Phase 2 on track for July 2028. In the procedural case from Richmond County, the Appellate Division reversed on standing on November 4, and the rollout stands. The city told the court it would not invoice the surcharge before November 15, 2026 or collect before January 1, 2027. DOF exemptions had reduced the properties still potentially subject to fewer than 9,000 as of November 4, 2026, according to The Real Deal.
Conquest's free DOF market-value and surcharge checker shows the Phase 1 exposure for any address. Phase 2 figures cannot be calculated until DOF publishes the comparable-sales data and methodology. Owners considering a sale, a lease to a qualifying tenant, or a transfer to a family member should consult their own tax adviser or attorney before the Phase 2 transition takes effect.
Frequently asked questions
Does the pied-à-terre tax rate change in July 2028?
Yes. From July 1, 2028, condos and co-ops move to the schedule that already applies to houses: no surcharge below $5 million, 0.8 percent from $5 million to $15 million, 1.05 percent from $15 million to $25 million and 1.3 percent above $25 million, each applied to the full value. The value itself also changes, from today's DOF market value to one based on comparable sales.
How will my condo be valued under Phase 2 of the pied-à-terre tax?
Phase 2 would replace the DOF market value method with one based on actual sales of comparable units. The statute does not specify which sales DOF will use, how recent they must be, or how DOF will adjust for differences in size, condition or location.
Is my apartment subject to the pied-à-terre tax if I challenge the valuation?
Owners who missed the October 13, 2026 exemption deadline may still challenge DOF's valuation or primary-residence determination through the Tax Commission; the deadline for Tax Class 2 properties is March 1, 2027, and for Tax Class 1 properties March 15, 2027. A successful procedural challenge could require corrected notices or revised determinations but would not repeal the statute or eliminate the July 1, 2028 transition.