What the surcharge is and when payment is due
New York City's non-primary-residence surcharge—commonly called the pied-à-terre tax—took effect July 1, 2026 under Tax Law Article 30-C and Chapter 32 of Title 11 of the Administrative Code. It applies to certain one- to three-family homes, condominiums and cooperative dwelling units that DOF determines are not the primary residence of the owner, an immediate family member or a qualifying tenant.
DOF mailed initial-determination notices to roughly 17,000 properties in August 2026. The city told Suffolk County Supreme Court it would not invoice the surcharge before November 15, 2026 or collect before January 1, 2027. Delinquent payments accrue the same interest rate that applies to property-tax delinquencies, the Comptroller reported November 4, 2026.
Conquest's analysis of DOF's July 2026 Supplemental Market Value Roll shows 24,173 units citywide would owe the surcharge if they are non-primary residences. Most are primary residences and owe nothing; the figure is an exposure count, not a forecast of what the city will collect.
What 'paying under protest' means in New York practice
In New York property-tax practice, paying under protest means making the required payment while preserving the taxpayer's position that the charge is unlawful, excessive or otherwise not owed. The payment avoids treating nonpayment as the taxpayer's chosen remedy; the taxpayer then pursues the available administrative appeal, refund or judicial remedy.
That distinction matters because nonpayment exposes the account to the ordinary consequences of delinquency, including interest. The NYC Comptroller's November 4, 2026 report states that delinquent surcharge payments would accrue the same interest rate applicable to property-tax delinquencies.
The materials reviewed do not identify a special statutory phrase, form or filing labeled 'payment under protest' for the Article 30-C surcharge. Nor do they establish that writing 'paid under protest' on a check, payment portal or tax bill alone preserves a refund claim. Counsel therefore treat the issue separately from payment: payment addresses delinquency, while a timely objection, appeal and refund application preserve the substantive claim.
DOF's appeal procedure and the Tax Commission deadline
DOF's final rules, adopted in 2026, provide that an owner or an authorized person for a covered cooperative property may appeal an initial determination within 30 days after the date the initial-determination notice is transmitted by DOF, or within 30 days after the surcharge appears on the assessment roll if DOF does not transmit that notice.
For the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2026, the statement of account and assessment roll together constitute notice of imposition; the rule also provides that notice that a payment is due and payable and the assessment roll constitute notice for that first fiscal year. DOF announced an extension for appeals of initial determinations through September 18, 2026.
For the 2026/27 and 2027/28 tax years, the NYC Tax Commission states that the deadline for a non-primary-residence surcharge appeal is March 1, 2027 for Tax Class Two properties and March 15, 2027 for Tax Class One properties, when the owner appeals both DOF's primary-residence determination and market-value determination to the Tax Commission at the same time. If the owner first appeals the residency determination to DOF, the owner may appeal DOF's final determination to the Tax Commission by the applicable March deadline or within 30 days of the date on DOF's final-determination notice, whichever is later.
Refund mechanics and the six-year window
The final DOF rule states that DOF may make refunds of surcharge overpayments and double payments under the NYC rules governing property-tax refunds. DOF's general refund page states that most property-tax credits are applied to the next bill unless the taxpayer requests a refund, that DOF asks taxpayers to allow eight weeks to process a refund claim, and that credit balances must be used or refunded within six years.
The materials reviewed do not establish a separate Article 30-C refund-application deadline, nor do they state that a general refund request preserves every legal challenge to the surcharge. The final rule's reference to refunds for overpayments and double payments also does not, by itself, resolve whether a taxpayer may recover a payment based on an invalid assessment after exhausting the applicable protest and appeal procedures.
The DOF rulemaking comments observed that the statute and proposed regulations did not create a clear refund mechanism for a taxpayer claiming that the surcharge was improperly imposed. The final rule added the general overpayment and double-payment language, but the available sources do not show that all uncertainty identified in the comments has been eliminated.
Two constitutional challenges are pending
The November 4, 2026 Appellate Division, Second Department decision in O'Brien v. City of New York reversed a lower-court order that had annulled DOF's rollout, holding that the petitioners lack standing because appearing on the roll or receiving a notice is not an injury. The rollout, roll and notices stand. The merits of the rollout were not decided, and the statute's validity was never at issue in that case.
Two constitutional challenges to the statute itself are pending in Suffolk County Supreme Court against New York State: Steve Wynn with Wilbur and Hilary Geary Ross v. State, filed September 28, 2026, argues a property tax that falls only on non-residents is unconstitutional; a group of homeowners plus a NYC co-op, represented by Randy Mastro and Dechert, filed a second challenge September 29, 2026. No decision as of November 10, 2026. Mastro has said he expects a decision around December 2026—that is his expectation, not a court date.
DOF exemptions had reduced the properties still potentially subject to fewer than 9,000 by November 4, 2026, The Real Deal reported. The exemption-application deadline for the 2026/27 fiscal year is October 13, 2026, extended by DOF on October 6, 2026 from October 6 to October 13.
What to watch and where to check your exposure
Owners who received a DOF notice and believe the property qualifies for an exemption should confirm whether they filed the exemption application by the October 13, 2026 deadline. Owners who did not file and who believe the surcharge was improperly imposed should consult counsel on whether the Tax Commission appeal deadlines—March 1, 2027 for Tax Class Two, March 15, 2027 for Tax Class One—or the 30-day post-final-determination window applies to their situation.
The Suffolk County constitutional challenges remain the only litigation testing the statute's validity. A decision in those cases would clarify whether the surcharge itself is lawful, but no court has ruled on that question as of November 17, 2026.
Conquest maintains a free DOF market-value and surcharge checker at secondhometax.nyc. Enter your address to see the DOF market value on file and the surcharge that would apply if the property is determined to be non-primary. The tool is updated from DOF's July 2026 Supplemental Market Value Roll. This article is educational content from Conquest, a licensed brokerage, and is not legal or tax advice.
Frequently asked questions
Is my apartment subject to the NYC pied-à-terre tax?
The surcharge applies to certain one- to three-family homes, condominiums and cooperative dwelling units that DOF determines are not the primary residence of the owner, an immediate family member or a qualifying tenant. DOF mailed initial-determination notices to roughly 17,000 properties in August 2026, and exemptions had reduced the properties still potentially subject to fewer than 9,000 by November 4, 2026.
How do I appeal the non-primary-residence surcharge determination?
For the 2026/27 and 2027/28 tax years, the NYC Tax Commission states that the deadline for a non-primary-residence surcharge appeal is March 1, 2027 for Tax Class Two properties and March 15, 2027 for Tax Class One properties. If you first appeal the residency determination to DOF, you may appeal DOF's final determination to the Tax Commission by the applicable March deadline or within 30 days of the date on DOF's final-determination notice, whichever is later.
Does paying the pied-à-terre tax under protest preserve my right to a refund?
The materials reviewed do not identify a special statutory phrase, form or filing labeled 'payment under protest' for the Article 30-C surcharge, nor do they establish that writing 'paid under protest' on a check alone preserves a refund claim. Counsel therefore treat the issue separately from payment: payment addresses delinquency, while a timely objection, appeal and refund application preserve the substantive claim.